LaTex2Web logo

Documents Live, a web authoring and publishing system

If you see this, something is wrong

Table of contents

First published on Saturday, Jan 11, 2025 and last modified on Saturday, Jan 11, 2025

Linear Algebra in the Euclidian Space: Section 12 Test

Fabienne Chaplais Mathedu

Keywords: Singular Values, SVD

1 Introduction

In that test, you will use the fact that, for any \( 2\times 2\) matrix \( A\) with real elements, the matrix \( A^TA\) is symmetric and thus, as you have seen in the section 11 test, it is diagonalizable in an orthonormal basis, to define the singular values of \( A\) .

For all the test, assume that \( A\) is a \( 2\times 2\) matrix with real elements.

2 Question 1: \( X^TA^TAX\) is always positive or zero

Assume that \( X\) is a column vector with two real elements.

Prove that \( X^TA^TAX\ge 0\) .

2.1 TIP:

Consider the linear mapping \( f:\mathbb{P}\rightarrow\mathbb{P}\) with matrix \( A\) in the canonical basis, and the vector \( \overrightarrow{u}\in\mathbb{P}\) with column vector of coordinates \( X\) in the canonical basis.

3 Question 2: \( Y^TDY\) is always positive or zero

Consider a unitary matrix \( U\) and the diagonal matrix \( D\) such that \( A^TA=UDU^T\) .

Consider the vector \( \overrightarrow{u}\in\mathbb{P}\) with column vector of coordinates \( X\) in the canonical basis.

Then the coordinates of \( \overrightarrow{u}\) in the basis made of the vectors with column vectors of coordinates in the canonical basis the columns of \( A\) are \( Y=U^{-1}X=U^TX\) .

Prove that \( Y^TDY=X^TA^TAX\ge 0\) .

3.1 TIP:

Use the fact that \( U\) is unitary to express \( D\) as a function of \( A\) and \( U\) .

4 Question 3: The eigenvalues of \( A^TA\) are positive or zero

Use the previous question to prove that the eigenvalues of \( A^TA\) are all positive or zero.

Use the fact that the diagonal elements \( \lambda_1\) and \( \lambda_2\) of matrix \( D\) considered in the previous question are the eigenvalues of \( A^TA\) , and consider the vectors \( Y\) with elements \( 1\) and \( 0\) and \( 0\) and \( 1\) .

Consequently, as \( \lambda_1\) and \( \lambda_2\) are the eigenvalues of \( A^TA\) , the eigenvalues of \( A^TA\) are positive or zero.

5 Question 4: If the singular values of \( A\) are positive, then \( A^TA\) is invertible

The singular values of \( A\) are defined as the square roots of the eigenvalues of \( A^TA\) .

Assume that the singular values of \( A\) are non zero, that is that they are positive.

\begin{myList}{numbered} \item Prove that \( A^TA\) is invertible.

5.1 TIP:

Consider the unitary matrix \( U\) and the diagonal matrix \( D\) such that \( A^TA=UDU^T\) .

\item Prove by contradiction that \( A\) is invertible.

5.2 TIP:

Use the fact that a matrix \( M\) is not invertible if and only if there exits a non zero column vector \( X\) such that \( MX=O_{21}\) , the null column vector. \end{myList}

6 Question 5: If \( A\) has a singular value \( 0\) , then \( 0\) is an eigenvalue of \( A\)

Assume that \( 0\) is a singular value of \( A\) , so that \( 0\) is an eigenvalue of \( A^TA\) , and consider a column vector \( X\) such that \( A^TAX=O_{21}\) , the null column vector.

Prove that \( AX=O_{21}\) , so that \( 0\) is an eigenvalue of \( A\) .

6.1 TIP:

Use the fact that \( X^TA^TAX\) is the square of the norm of the vector \( f(\overrightarrow{u})\) , where \( f\) is the linear mapping with matrix \( A\) in the canonical basis, and \( \overrightarrow{u}\in\mathbb{P}\) is the vector with column vector of coordinates \( X\) in the canonical basis.

7 Question 6: If \( 0\) is a singular value of \( A\) , then \( A\) is not invertible.

Prove by contradiction that if \( 0\) is a singular value of \( A\) , then \( A\) is not invertible.

7.1 TIP:

Consider a non zero column vector \( X\) such that \( A^TAX=O_{21}\) , the null column vector.

8 Conclusion

We have proved the following facts.

  • The singular values of a \( 2\times 2\) matrix with real elements are all positive or zero.

  • If the eigenvalues of a matrix are positive, then that matrix is invertible.

  • A matrix having \( 0\) as singular value is not invertible.

We have thus proved that a matrix is invertible if and only if its singular values are positive.